A Major Conundrum Solved

The big question of the day was "Why does the engine badly miss when I go over 2,900 RPM"?

It would be fine during takeoff, climb, cruise, etc., but the engine would badly miss when I went over 2,900. Was it the electronic ignition? A bad coil? Problems with fuel delivery? Since these systems are interwoven I wasn't sure where to start.

I thought I had already conquered the case of the vibrating sensor mounting bracket but in the back of my mind, the miss felt familiar. Since I had already beefed up the assembly, I didn't know what I could to do to make it better and I didn't want to spend a lot of effort there if I didn't know that was the problem.

I decided to shoot Lynn French an e-mail and ask for a gigantic favor. If I flew to Broken Bow Nebraska, would he consent to swapping parts - again? Fortunately, Lynn is very generous and he went along with the plan.

On the way to Broken Bow I stopped in Topeka to see my daughter and grand-kids, so I did get some great non-aviation time, too.

While I was en-route, I tried going to WOT a couple of times and each time the miss was back.

I arrived at the Broken Bow airport about 10:00, Lynn arranged a nice hangar to work in and parts started flying off the planes. We set them up nose-to nose and installed Lynn's bracket bracket and trigger wheel. Rob Martinson brought doughnuts from Colorado in his newly rebuilt Long-Eze, and took a look at our electronic ignition set-ups.

Here is Lynn's current set up:


Fortunately, it was a simple swap. I didn't have to change the timing or anything, and I used my sensors. We just changed the trigger wheel and mounting bracket. After a quick test on the ground, everything seemed well. I told Lynn that I would take it up and see how it was, that if it performed well I would just fly on home. (just kidding).

Here are Lynn's parts mounted in my buggy:

So, I went up for the test hop and what do you know? The engine performed just fine, smooth as a baby's butt. At WOT the engine was perfectly smooth and no hint of a miss. Problem diagnosed. It was somewhere in my trigger wheel mounting bracket setup and I'm pretty sure it was a vibration issue creating electronic noise in the sensors.

Got back on the ground and we put the parts in their proper places, and left the airport just as the sun was setting.

On top of all that, Lynn was nice enough to boot one of his boys out of his room and give me a bed to sleep in. Great guy.

One screwy thing, I tried another in-flight WOT on the way home and the miss was gone. This is not completely surprising, since it had previously behaved on occasion. I think my mounting system is just on the edge of performing/not performing, and when we swapped the parts I may have set it in a more reliable position.

Here is a photo of my view of Nebraska on the way back to Topeka:

Having said all that, I still need to work out a more reliable system. I have several options and I'll mull the whole thing over, before I come up with my final direction.

Thanks again, Lynn.

I Finally Figured It Out

That's what my dad always used to say, "I finally figured it out". He was always talking about the meaning of life. In my case, I just want to figure out how to make the damn engine run.

Thanks to Lynn French, I definitely know the ignition problem is due to my trigger wheel and sensor assembly. Lynn was kind enough to lend me his parts, while his engine is down, and I bolted it on this afternoon. Lynn has the 7" trigger wheel, while I have the 6". I used my existing sensor and wiring.

The engine fired up just fine, as always. After it warmed up I ran it all the way to 2,320 RPM. I haven't seen the engine turn that fast and smooth in a year and a half. While I was at WOT I switched off the mag and the engine didn't miss a beat.

Here are some photos of Lynn's trigger assembly mounted on my plane. Compare them with my installation in my previous post, dated April 19.


So, without a doubt, the smaller wheel must be causing me to pick up noise from the crank flange and prop bolts.

That's the good news.

Now, I have to figure out what to do about it. My first inclination is to see if I can find a different sensor and use the existing wheel. I have a lot of $$$ in that trigger wheel, and looking at Lynn's parts, I'm sure he even has far more machining than mine. I know a rep for an industrial sensor company and I'll give him a call tomorrow.

Maybe I could use an aluminum plate, with the embedded magnets, like Klaus uses. I would have to know if that type of Hall Effect device would work with the EC3.



Any other ideas?